The TTRPG market aches for a good Urban Fantasy game.
Moderator: Moderators
-
- Invincible Overlord
- Posts: 10555
- Joined: Thu Sep 25, 2008 3:00 am
The TTRPG market aches for a good Urban Fantasy game.
So if you want a good (or at least supported) TTRPG that you can play urban fantasy games in, you're pretty much limited to WoD and Shadowrun. It's not that they're bad settings, it's that they're specific settings that hinder adventures.
Considering the popularity of urban fantasy (various low-powered superhero books, those dumb monster mash books, Buffy and Angel, Charmed, various anime, the latter Harry Potter books) the fact that no one has tried to make a Generic Urban Fantasy setting in the style of D&D is to me very baffling. There's a lot of cross-market potential here and you also know that you already have interest in the sub-demographics. A game where you can convince a DC comics fan, a Heroes fan, a Harry Potter fan, and a Twilight fan to sit together at the table seems like money in the bank. So... what the hey?
Considering the popularity of urban fantasy (various low-powered superhero books, those dumb monster mash books, Buffy and Angel, Charmed, various anime, the latter Harry Potter books) the fact that no one has tried to make a Generic Urban Fantasy setting in the style of D&D is to me very baffling. There's a lot of cross-market potential here and you also know that you already have interest in the sub-demographics. A game where you can convince a DC comics fan, a Heroes fan, a Harry Potter fan, and a Twilight fan to sit together at the table seems like money in the bank. So... what the hey?
Josh Kablack wrote:Your freedom to make rulings up on the fly is in direct conflict with my freedom to interact with an internally consistent narrative. Your freedom to run/play a game without needing to understand a complex rule system is in direct conflict with my freedom to play a character whose abilities and flaws function as I intended within that ruleset. Your freedom to add and change rules in the middle of the game is in direct conflict with my ability to understand that rules system before I decided whether or not to join your game.
In short, your entire post is dismissive of not merely my intelligence, but my agency. And I don't mean agency as a player within one of your games, I mean my agency as a person. You do not want me to be informed when I make the fundamental decisions of deciding whether to join your game or buying your rules system.
Re: The TTRPG market aches for a good Urban Fantasy game.
Magic works differently in all of your examples, correct? So how would you try to simulate all of those types of stories using one system unless it's a generic system like GURPS or Hero? Or FATE, which is the basis of the recent Dresden Files RPG?Lago PARANOIA wrote: Considering the popularity of urban fantasy (various low-powered superhero books, those dumb monster mash books, Buffy and Angel, Charmed, various anime, the latter Harry Potter books) the fact that no one has tried to make a Generic Urban Fantasy setting in the style of D&D is to me very baffling.
- Psychic Robot
- Prince
- Posts: 4607
- Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 10:47 pm
A lot of the attempts we're seeing for stuff like this move away from modeling the powers and more on modeling the character dynamics, like in the Smallville RPG. Not saying you don't have a point, just that more and more the "character drama" series are becoming rules light games which try to avoid modelling the abilities of characters specifically and focus on modelling a kind of narrative, with the abilities being a secondary thing.
-
- Duke
- Posts: 1545
- Joined: Fri Jul 17, 2009 2:07 am
Most of your examples are wish-fulfillement wank.
People who do wish-fulfillement wank tend to suck at math, so there's a tendence to crap mechanics, unless an unwieldy simulation system is adapted.
Besides, I believe that the market for wish-fulfillement wank is already covered by White Wolf. So, you are agaist the oWoD inertia.
People who do wish-fulfillement wank tend to suck at math, so there's a tendence to crap mechanics, unless an unwieldy simulation system is adapted.
Besides, I believe that the market for wish-fulfillement wank is already covered by White Wolf. So, you are agaist the oWoD inertia.
-
- Knight-Baron
- Posts: 738
- Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2011 6:35 pm
It's not bad. If you've played with FATE at all, you know what's involved. Mechanics *heavily* take a backseat to narration, however - to the point that you get bonuses based upon using specific words in your action description.CapnTthePirateG wrote:What about the Dresden Files RPG? Never played it, but if it's faithful to the books it's pretty kitchen-sinkish.
echo
There's already a Buffy and Angel RPG:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffyverse ... ying_games
http://www.edenstudios.net/buffyrpg.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unisystem
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffyverse ... ying_games
http://www.edenstudios.net/buffyrpg.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unisystem
Koumei wrote:I'm just glad that Jill Stein stayed true to her homeopathic principles by trying to win with .2% of the vote. She just hasn't diluted it enough!
Koumei wrote:I am disappointed in Santorum: he should carry his dead election campaign to term!
Just a heads up... Your post is pregnant... When you miss that many periods it's just a given.
]I want him to tongue-punch my box.
The divine in me says the divine in you should go fuck itself.
-
- Invincible Overlord
- Posts: 10555
- Joined: Thu Sep 25, 2008 3:00 am
Obviously we're not trying to replicate those stories, just the kinds of stories. Harry Potter has a specific flavor of magic for its setting, so if you were doing a generalized game you would have to sketch it more broadly. So you can have domination and killing curses and just say that different magic schools call them different thing (vampires call theirs the Evil Eye), but a Bat Bogey hex would either have to be left out or be reskinned. But once you get that down, it's not that hard to replicate the main metaplot and flavor of Harry Potter: teenage magicians in a backwards subculture struggle in a series of cloak and dagger missions to stop a supernatural racial supremacy dictator and his minions from gaining ultimate political and phlebtonium-based power. From there you can add Teen Titans animesque Robin, Static Shock, Sailor Moon (the nerfed anime version), and Yusuke Urameshi and while you won't be able to replicate the story exactly you'll get a really close general gist.hogarth wrote: Magic works differently in all of your examples, correct? So how would you try to simulate all of those types of stories using one system unless it's a generic system like GURPS or Hero? Or FATE, which is the basis of the recent Dresden Files RPG?
And I think that this is a bad direction to go because it creates a false dichotomy between 'what you want the story to be' and 'what the characters can do' and when you do this it creates utter bullshit like high-level Final Fantasy characters being thwarted by fences and Wonder Woman not pulling out her lasso on a mass murder suspect.Almaz wrote:Not saying you don't have a point, just that more and more the "character drama" series are becoming rules light games which try to avoid modelling the abilities of characters specifically and focus on modelling a kind of narrative, with the abilities being a secondary thing.
Even if that is the state of such settings in general, the next TTRPG doesn't have to ape it. I suspect that instead of it being something that people want it's just something that people expect and thus put with, like THAC0 and per-kill experience points and privatized health care.
1) Yeah, because D&D and cyberpunk and superhero fiction aren't infamous for indulging in nerd fantasies. And we all know wish fulfillment is bad and doesn't sell because of how shameless it is. That's a WoD-specific criticism, doncha know.Gx1080 wrote: Besides, I believe that the market for wish-fulfillement wank is already covered by White Wolf. So, you are agaist the oWoD inertia.
2) White Wolf isn't cornering anything these days. WoD is extremely moribund. If someone wanted to put out a dark urban fantasy product and had a competent marketing team and rules set they could take them out in like in three or four years.
3) The WoD games is actually an extremely specific set of urban fantasy. If Hunter wasn't so crap you could probably model Buffy, but doing Harry Potter, Teen Titans (the comic book version), Sailor Moon, or Indiana Jones is out of the question. Even if you could replicate the mechanics the tone would clash with the game. It'd be like wanting Shadowrun to replicate the adventures of Green Arrow and Blue Beetle and Zatanna. On a strict mechanical level you could do so but the theme of the characters and their adventures would be dissonant with the metaplot.
Last edited by Lago PARANOIA on Mon Jun 20, 2011 6:28 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Josh Kablack wrote:Your freedom to make rulings up on the fly is in direct conflict with my freedom to interact with an internally consistent narrative. Your freedom to run/play a game without needing to understand a complex rule system is in direct conflict with my freedom to play a character whose abilities and flaws function as I intended within that ruleset. Your freedom to add and change rules in the middle of the game is in direct conflict with my ability to understand that rules system before I decided whether or not to join your game.
In short, your entire post is dismissive of not merely my intelligence, but my agency. And I don't mean agency as a player within one of your games, I mean my agency as a person. You do not want me to be informed when I make the fundamental decisions of deciding whether to join your game or buying your rules system.
-
- Prince
- Posts: 2606
- Joined: Fri Apr 30, 2010 11:43 pm
They have a sailor moon RPG. It uses the tri-stat system and is one of the most horrible implementations of a game I've ever seen. A starting character has on average one attack per day that actually does any damage, if you don't build your character to be a combat twink odds are you'll miss your one attack, and then you get one minor ability that is more or less useless.
The one session we tried I attacked someone once, missed, ran away screaming like a little girl because I was literally helpless, and for the rest of the session I literally could only make people's hair ruffle dramatically in the wind.
I do question though how much of a market interest there is in playing the types of games you're talking about. WOD was about roleplaying the bad guy and being a vampire or other supernatural monster. That it was set in modern days was ancillary, as can be seen by the continuing fan base for dark ages WOD.
The one session we tried I attacked someone once, missed, ran away screaming like a little girl because I was literally helpless, and for the rest of the session I literally could only make people's hair ruffle dramatically in the wind.
I do question though how much of a market interest there is in playing the types of games you're talking about. WOD was about roleplaying the bad guy and being a vampire or other supernatural monster. That it was set in modern days was ancillary, as can be seen by the continuing fan base for dark ages WOD.
- RobbyPants
- King
- Posts: 5201
- Joined: Wed Aug 06, 2008 6:11 pm
If you are talking about Sailor Moon, no where since Guardians of Order when belly up some years ago. So the only way to get that is torrents.RobbyPants wrote:Slightly off topic, but where can you buy the PDF?
Now you could try to recreate it with Tri-Stat dX.
http://rpg.drivethrustuff.com/product_i ... cts_id=368
Last edited by Leress on Mon Jun 20, 2011 7:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Koumei wrote:I'm just glad that Jill Stein stayed true to her homeopathic principles by trying to win with .2% of the vote. She just hasn't diluted it enough!
Koumei wrote:I am disappointed in Santorum: he should carry his dead election campaign to term!
Just a heads up... Your post is pregnant... When you miss that many periods it's just a given.
]I want him to tongue-punch my box.
The divine in me says the divine in you should go fuck itself.
- RobbyPants
- King
- Posts: 5201
- Joined: Wed Aug 06, 2008 6:11 pm
- PoliteNewb
- Duke
- Posts: 1053
- Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2009 1:23 am
- Location: Alaska
- Contact:
For a modern-base game that models a wide variety of "powers", I kinda like the Godlike ORE (one roll engine).
Godlike is WWII supers, and very setting specific. But the actual mechanics are pretty simple and versatile. It's designed so you can set up pretty much any superpower you can imagine, so that should work pretty well for Potter-esque spells (for instance). You could ditch the "battle of wills" mechanics if they felt too clunky, or leave them in (as a vague counterspelling concept).
If you wanted something non-powered, like Indiana Jones...you probably want a pulp heroes game. I've heard decent things about Spirit of the Century, but have never played it or read it.
Godlike is WWII supers, and very setting specific. But the actual mechanics are pretty simple and versatile. It's designed so you can set up pretty much any superpower you can imagine, so that should work pretty well for Potter-esque spells (for instance). You could ditch the "battle of wills" mechanics if they felt too clunky, or leave them in (as a vague counterspelling concept).
If you wanted something non-powered, like Indiana Jones...you probably want a pulp heroes game. I've heard decent things about Spirit of the Century, but have never played it or read it.
I am judging the philosophies and decisions you have presented in this thread. The ones I have seen look bad, and also appear to be the fruit of a poisonous tree that has produced only madness and will continue to produce only madness.
--AngelFromAnotherPin
believe in one hand and shit in the other and see which ones fills up quicker. it will be the one you are full of, shit.
--Shadzar
--AngelFromAnotherPin
believe in one hand and shit in the other and see which ones fills up quicker. it will be the one you are full of, shit.
--Shadzar
Okay, if "sorta close" is good enough, then why don't World of Darkness, Dresden Files RPG, Buffy RPG, etc. fit your definition of "Generic Urban Fantasy"? Or do you mean really, really generic a la FATE/GURPS/Hero, in which case, why don't those fit your definition?Lago PARANOIA wrote:Obviously we're not trying to replicate those stories, just the kinds of stories.hogarth wrote: Magic works differently in all of your examples, correct? So how would you try to simulate all of those types of stories using one system unless it's a generic system like GURPS or Hero? Or FATE, which is the basis of the recent Dresden Files RPG?
-
- Serious Badass
- Posts: 29894
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm
What would make an Urban Fantasy setting "generic"? The entire concept is basically that you take "Our Vampires Are Different" and start telling a story. But if your vampires catch fire in sunlight that is a different setting than one where they don't. And if some vampires catch fire in sunlight and others don't, that is a different setting still. You said it yourself:Lago wrote:Considering the popularity of urban fantasy (various low-powered superhero books, those dumb monster mash books, Buffy and Angel, Charmed, various anime, the latter Harry Potter books) the fact that no one has tried to make a Generic Urban Fantasy setting in the style of D&D is to me very baffling.
Look: V:tM is just all the vampire tropes that 10 years of authors could think of thrown into a blender. And that's still a specific setting. It's not even possible to have an Urban Fantasy game and have it not be a specific setting.Lago wrote:So if you want a good (or at least supported) TTRPG that you can play urban fantasy games in, you're pretty much limited to WoD and Shadowrun. It's not that they're bad settings, it's that they're specific settings that hinder adventures.
Consider the basic Monster of the Week plot format for Urban Fantasy. It doesn't really matter whether we're talking a piece of Harry Potter filler or an episode of Angel for this purpose. There's a monster who has some magic powers, it is identified, and then the heroes use magical lore to use the weaknesses of the monster against it, roll credits. Now think about that for a moment. Think about it in the context of the heroes being players instead of puppets in a single-author fiction piece. The "magical lore" and the "weaknesses" part of the game don't come from first principles, they come from the setting.
That's the core difference between Urban Fantasy and Tolkienian Fantasy. In pseudo-medieval land, your go-to solution to problems is to stab them in the face with a sword. That's amenable to being labeled "generic" because the players don't need to consult the setting to determine which end of the sword goes into their opponents. But if the way people solve problems is to interact with the magic, then the rules the magic has are the setting and "genericness" is not possible.
-Username17
- Psychic Robot
- Prince
- Posts: 4607
- Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 10:47 pm
pretty sure that none of those games count as "good"Okay, if "sorta close" is good enough, then why don't World of Darkness, Dresden Files RPG, Buffy RPG, etc. fit your definition of "Generic Urban Fantasy"? Or do you mean really, really generic a la FATE/GURPS/Hero, in which case, why don't those fit your definition?
wod is okay despite the hate that it gets, but mage is probably not the kind of magic you're going to want in urban fantasy. also everythin wod writes is tied to fluff which means a lot of reworking if you want more generic mechanics
Count Arioch wrote:I'm not sure how discussions on whether PR is a terrible person or not is on-topic.
Ant wrote:You do not seem to do anything.Chamomile wrote:Ant, what do we do about Psychic Robot?
First off, I didn't said "White Wolf", I said the oWoD inertia. It's a half-decent game, that is getting reprints, and while is perfectly possible to compete, and even drive it out the market, you are not covering new ground, you are basically doing a WoD without the suck.
And I'm probably biased, since I find the Urban Fantasy fanbase utterly depisable.
And I'm probably biased, since I find the Urban Fantasy fanbase utterly depisable.
- Psychic Robot
- Prince
- Posts: 4607
- Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 10:47 pm
tbh I find most of the ttrpg fanbase despicableAnd I'm probably biased, since I find the Urban Fantasy fanbase utterly depisable.
Count Arioch wrote:I'm not sure how discussions on whether PR is a terrible person or not is on-topic.
Ant wrote:You do not seem to do anything.Chamomile wrote:Ant, what do we do about Psychic Robot?
Then "there should be something like X, except better" is a statement that's so vague it borders on meaningless.Psychic Robot wrote:pretty sure that none of those games count as "good"Okay, if "sorta close" is good enough, then why don't World of Darkness, Dresden Files RPG, Buffy RPG, etc. fit your definition of "Generic Urban Fantasy"? Or do you mean really, really generic a la FATE/GURPS/Hero, in which case, why don't those fit your definition?
D&D manages to be a generic setting even though their trolls regenerate, their demons and devils hate each other, their Paladins have a specific code of conduct spelled out in the PHB, genies can grant exactly three wishes but only for non-genies, and so on and so forth. Why is practically all magic Vancian? Because it's a D&D setting, and the fact that you made up a new geography doesn't change that.
Similarly, just because you don't want to establish that Death Eaters, the Camarilla, and the Watcher Council are rubbing shoulders in New York City doesn't mean you can't establish that vampires lose their superpowers in sunlight.
Similarly, just because you don't want to establish that Death Eaters, the Camarilla, and the Watcher Council are rubbing shoulders in New York City doesn't mean you can't establish that vampires lose their superpowers in sunlight.
- Darth Rabbitt
- Overlord
- Posts: 8870
- Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2009 8:31 pm
- Location: In "In The Trenches," mostly.
- Contact:
I'd say that regenerating trolls and genies granting three wishes to non-genies are now common in fantasy, even though that's probably just due to D&D's influence on later fantasy RPGs.
But your larger point still stands.
But your larger point still stands.
Last edited by Darth Rabbitt on Tue Jun 21, 2011 3:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Pseudo Stupidity wrote:This Applebees fucking sucks, much like all Applebees. I wanted to go to Femboy Hooters (communism).
- CatharzGodfoot
- King
- Posts: 5668
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm
- Location: North Carolina
The three wishes is folkloric. Regenerating trolls is, to my knowledge, just the enshrinement of a DM deciding to turn a bridge-lurking giant into a puzzle monster by giving it the power of the Hydra.
The law in its majestic equality forbids the rich as well as the poor from stealing bread, begging and sleeping under bridges.
-Anatole France
Mount Flamethrower on rear
Drive in reverse
Win Game.
-Josh Kablack
-Anatole France
Mount Flamethrower on rear
Drive in reverse
Win Game.
-Josh Kablack
The regenerating troll is from Three Hearts and Three Lions by Poul Anderson.CatharzGodfoot wrote:The three wishes is folkloric. Regenerating trolls is, to my knowledge, just the enshrinement of a DM deciding to turn a bridge-lurking giant into a puzzle monster by giving it the power of the Hydra.
It's a mishmash of a bunch of different sources, but I don't know how that makes it "generic". That's like saying Rifts is a generic setting.Chamomile wrote:D&D manages to be a generic setting even though their trolls regenerate, their demons and devils hate each other, their Paladins have a specific code of conduct spelled out in the PHB, genies can grant exactly three wishes but only for non-genies, and so on and so forth.