Search found 892 matches

by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 8:59 pm
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: 4e is now dead to me.
Replies: 123
Views: 8829

Re: 4e is now dead to me.

1197100661[/unixtime]] 1196995377[/unixtime]]Also each color has a personality. [br][br]So alignments would be booted in favour of "Detect Blue" and "Smite Green"? That is awesome.[br][br]Regarding unkillable NPCs: Fucking Halastar the Insane Bastard. [br]But detect blue would b...
by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 8:55 pm
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Someone's making a True20 Shadowrun
Replies: 11
Views: 975

Re: Someone's making a True20 Shadowrun

RandomCasualty at [unixtime wrote:1197118737[/unixtime]]A level based system with hitpoints tends to really suck for doing futuristic gun based settings.

Thankfully Trued20 has no HP.
by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 7:18 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: How many attributes for your attribute-based game?
Replies: 3
Views: 710

How many attributes for your attribute-based game?

Flavor-wise, not for balance (there's been good discussion of that already). I means for a purely attribute based game, where any roll you make will be based on your attributes alone (although level or equipment bonuses are fair game).[br][br]To cover the bases for a modern/future game, I think Shad...
by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 7:00 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: 4e is now dead to me.
Replies: 123
Views: 8829

Re: 4e is now dead to me.

Mearls is right. Sundering does fuck up the game, assuming the DM puts treasure on NPCs such that corpse-looting PCs will have exactly the right amount of crud per level if they take everything. And that's how the game is apparently intended to be played.[br][br][br]Ideally, sundering should be poss...
by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 12:54 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!
Replies: 114
Views: 12624

Re: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!

1197074479[/unixtime]][br]Since armour spikes are illogical to remove, since you know, it makes sense to cover yourself in weapons to keep monsters from bear-hugging you... [br][br]Heh. You're joking, right? Armor spikes would have to be carefully placed at some subset of {elbows, hands, head, and ...
by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 12:46 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Why have ability scores in skill rank driven games?
Replies: 44
Views: 3616

Re: Why have ability scores in skill rank driven games?

1197039171[/unixtime]][br]Though I still disagree with the whole 'shiny kitty + angry snake' shotgun issue of stats versus skills. It's not even a problem; just keep the points from skills and stats separate and refuse to let people exchange them.[br][br]I agree it is a problem in most point-based ...
by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 12:27 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!
Replies: 114
Views: 12624

Re: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!

1197062724[/unixtime]]Okay, where the heck is this legendary Kusari-gama found? It is the perfect weapon for the occasion, and I've google-searched several times with little to no success. I thought I found it in Oriental Adventures, but I suppose not. Please, tell me where it is, I beg you. [br]3....
by Catharz
Sat Dec 08, 2007 12:22 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Best System for Dragonlance?
Replies: 139
Views: 15725

Re: Best System for Dragonlance?

angelfromanotherpin at [unixtime wrote:1197059910[/unixtime]]That's why there's only four Shakers in the world...

I thought that was because Shakers didn't have children.
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 8:12 pm
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Why Frank's Tomes Have Not Caught On (In Some Circles)
Replies: 99
Views: 11211

Re: Why Frank's Tomes Have Not Caught On (In Some Circles)

1197039400[/unixtime]][br]So this really got me thinking...Some people don't like Frank and K's stuff because they claim it's broken/too powerful/etc.[br][br]What's the right answer to that, in a way that will let me continue talking to this guy on friendly terms? [br][br]There's often an assumptio...
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 7:20 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Why Frank's Tomes Have Not Caught On (In Some Circles)
Replies: 99
Views: 11211

Re: Why Frank's Tomes Have Not Caught On (In Some Circles)

1196995503[/unixtime]][br]I've been tempted to do a Penny Arcade thing where I just write content for DnD or a system of my own design and accept donations and advertising and make T-shirts and cups that say clever DnD type stuff. The only problem is that I've got this whole law school thing and Fr...
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 5:03 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!
Replies: 114
Views: 12624

Re: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!

Warmaster:[br]The 3.5e "kusari-gama" is a light slashing weapon (1d6 damage) with reach. You seem to be using the older (Oriental Adventures) version, which IIRC is a large reach OR double 1d6s/1d4b weapon.[br][br]There are certainly advantages to both (e.g. TWFing with just your ancestral...
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 4:27 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Best System for Dragonlance?
Replies: 139
Views: 15725

Re: Best System for Dragonlance?

Just run it in your regular house-ruled 3e and pretend it all makes sense. As others have said, Dragonlance isn't internally consistent enough to worry yourself over little things like the wish economy.[br][br]The best system would probably be some D20 -based thing you spent 900 hours to create, but...
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 1:51 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Why have ability scores in skill rank driven games?
Replies: 44
Views: 3616

Re: Why have ability scores in skill rank driven games?

Lago_AM3P at [unixtime wrote:1196990001[/unixtime]]
So how would a skill-only system handle this?

Probably as an increase in the Athletics or Acrobatics skill, of which parkour is a specialization.
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 1:45 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: 4e is now dead to me.
Replies: 123
Views: 8829

Re: 4e is now dead to me.

Black -> marsh
Blue -> oceanic
Green -> woods
Red -> mountains
White -> plains

Apparently inhospitable regions have no 'mana'.
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 12:48 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: 4e is now dead to me.
Replies: 123
Views: 8829

Re: 4e is now dead to me.

You could come up with generic groupings of like creatures, and call the the same (a la the "beast-headed giants" of Dark Sun).[br][br]I was also wondering whether color should be based on habitat. You've said that loci are Green. Does this mean that swamp loci are Green? If they are, you'...
by Catharz
Fri Dec 07, 2007 12:32 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Why have ability scores in skill rank driven games?
Replies: 44
Views: 3616

Re: Why have ability scores in skill rank driven games?

1196668692[/unixtime]][br]...[br]There are lots of perfectly valid methods to handle any particular situation which you want to model.[br][br]-Username17 [br]Yeah, the cap system seems to work well for that, provided that caps are only for total bonus. Depending on attribute and skill cost some cha...
by Catharz
Thu Dec 06, 2007 4:34 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: 4e is now dead to me.
Replies: 123
Views: 8829

Re: 4e is now dead to me.

If I was Mearls, I'd be scared. Fans like those are the type to kidnap you, or kill people to 'impress you'.

It's not the disgruntled rules lawyers he has to worry about...
by Catharz
Thu Dec 06, 2007 4:30 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Someone's making a True20 Shadowrun
Replies: 11
Views: 975

Re: Someone's making a True20 Shadowrun

Yeah, it's not a good fit. And it's needlessly complex and unbalanced from the offset, which is never a good idea when the entire point of the system is to be simple and balanced.

It probably wouldn't be worth trying (assuming it's fleshed out) even with a d20-versed, SR ignorant group.
by Catharz
Wed Dec 05, 2007 9:24 pm
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Energy Mages
Replies: 40
Views: 11634

Re: Energy Mages

It doesn't seem quite visceral enough. Acid splash, for example, could involve the character vomiting up the acid. You could make this a core ability, adding additional effects like nausea, poison, and disease to anyone hit by it.[br][br]There should probably be some type of mind affecting ability, ...
by Catharz
Wed Dec 05, 2007 9:03 pm
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!
Replies: 114
Views: 12624

Re: Tome Series - Character Creation Thread!

I thought this was a fun villain:[br][br]"The sweetest meat lies closest to the bone."[br]"It's best to eat your food fresh before the chi dissipates."[br]Ghoul [ToN] human[br] [br]Jester [Dun] 6/Thief of Souls [ToN] 9/Conduit of the Lower Planes 3[br]1:Jst 1 |--------------| 0| ...
by Catharz
Wed Dec 05, 2007 6:05 pm
Forum: In The Trenches
Topic: Give me a weapon fit for a Samurai!
Replies: 29
Views: 7780

Re: Give me a weapon fit for a Samurai!

If you're TWFing anyway, use a kusarigama in one hand and a heavy pick in the other. The base damage isn't especially high (IIRC only 1d6/id6), but for a crit/AoO fiend it's badass.

You can even pretend it's that weapon used by the Guns & Roses guy in Guilty Gear.
by Catharz
Wed Dec 05, 2007 5:08 pm
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: 4e is now dead to me.
Replies: 123
Views: 8829

Re: 4e is now dead to me.

1196860722[/unixtime]] 1196789806[/unixtime]]If you really think those two scenarios are lame, then the 'charge up' period would basically be painting a target long enough for the air strike to get them. [br][br]That really is the idea. Charge up on a target so you can kick that targets ass. No tra...
by Catharz
Wed Dec 05, 2007 2:46 am
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: Power Scale of Magic Items
Replies: 42
Views: 2601

Re: Power Scale of Magic Items

Prak_Anima at [unixtime wrote:1196819933[/unixtime]]how do the gauntlets and belt stack? they're both enhancement bonuses...
Because that's the special ability of an artifact.
by Catharz
Wed Dec 05, 2007 1:42 am
Forum: It's My Own Invention...
Topic: A Pair of Barbarian Prestige Classes and a new feat
Replies: 29
Views: 4937

Re: A Pair of Barbarian Prestige Classes and a new feat

The feats should be skill feats keyed to Intimidate.
by Catharz
Tue Dec 04, 2007 5:36 pm
Forum: In My Humble Opinion...
Topic: 4e is now dead to me.
Replies: 123
Views: 8829

Re: 4e is now dead to me.

1196771571[/unixtime]]Okay, you went for the extreme example. Heres something that might happen in a game.[br][br]You are beating on mooks for three rounds then the BBEG rocks up. You unload with your now charged maneuvers and he gets owned. That is probably not a desirable scenario. Importantly, t...