Utterfail wrote:You're being snarky, but hilariously, the ability to walk to the left is mechanical. Without at least a Dex score of 1 and a base land speed you can't walk, and there are many effects that can rob you of your mechanical ability to walk.
Yes, but on the average you don't need to roll to be able to walk, and likewise you don't have to roll for everything else either. It is when you have to put that one thing into the game that many people don't like....common sense.
One of the big complaints about skill challenges with 4th is still that it is "social combat". One side says it was done for those lacking social skills enough to talk during the game to do something, and at the same time to prevent DM fiat from unfairly denying people from succeeding at things because they are socially inept even to be able to play their own character.
That is when you change the DM, not add some new control for THEM to use. If they were abusing the players before, and since the DM runs the game; what makes you think the DM won't find a way to abuse the new system? So fix/replace the DM.
Another side says "skill challenges" streamline the game so you CAN just roll through the "social combat" and not have to bother with it. You can get back to the physical combat of the game quick (which is what is fun about the game) if you bypass that boring social interactions quicker.
Whatever happened to the side that likes roleplaying? The ones that don't need to constantly be rolling dice, and haggle with the merchants with real world words to encourage, and the decent DMs that could roleplay back.
If some people don't know how to do this, then when watching the DM and another play do it, they learn how. With always rolling dice, the roleplaying is being lost from the roleplaying game. It is just an adventure board game, where the character is your playing piece and you click the response or icon to signify the scripted action you wish to perform.
So like walking, most of the times other things can be done WITHOUT dice, and everyone needs to learn how to do them that way.
Futurama wrote:Gary Gygax: Greetings! It's a <rolls dice> pleasure to meet you!
http://www.veoh.com/collection/Fox-Futu ... 21xYtpT57m