Edisons of the Coast

[Prak]

Wizards has established a clause in their Forum ToS stating that all material submitted to the boards becomes their property. As I understand it, they cannot, legally, use material posted prior to the enstatement of this clause, however, to avoid theft of intellectual property, I encourage anyone who posted any material they hold precious to the wizards boards to remove it.

[the_taken]

Can they actually legally make money off of anything posted? I can understand this clause to shut up those that wave the "freedom of speech" card, when they want to post amoral and racist/sexist/stupidist statements.

[Prak]

I think that as long as they have provided people an opportunity to learn of this, then yes, they can.

[MrWaeseL]

STICKIN' IT TO THE MAN

[Leress]

All the stuff I put on there they an have.

[the_taken]

1187927848[/unixtime]]All the stuff I put on there they an have.

Word.

I haven't posted my best material there. I keep it all off line in a secret location.

[Caedrus]

Could you please point out where, specifically, this clause is mentioned?

[Koumei]

Heheheh, the mind flayer is performing the Yu-Gi-Oh Mind Crush...

Anyway, I also don't mind if they keep the crap I posted there. Let's see...

"You're a moron."
"Learn to read."
"You're entitled to your opinion, but you're still wrong."
"No, that's utter crap, you could give that monster an LA +0 and it'll still be shafted."
"Are you on crack?"

etc.

Seriously. They can keep my insults. The only rule-stuff I thought up and posted there was back before I understood balance. (and what affects it). "Ooh, 4+Int skills, Heritage feats at levels 1, 5, 10, 15 and 20 and a d6 Hit die will completely fix Sorcerers and make them as good as the Wizard."

[Leress]

1187935062[/unixtime]]Could you please point out where, specifically, this clause is mentioned?

http://ww2.wizards.com/Company/Misc/Ind ... egalnotice

[tzor]

I think they have stated that the clause is a CYA clause and they have no intention of specifically ripping off people's ideas without proper compensation. The problem is when they are working on an idea and someone independently publishes on the site the idea before they publish it.

Mind you I can no longer find the thread where the official stated this ... consider this heresay until proven otherwise. You may resume your parinoia.

[cthulhu]

Stuff like that is difficult to enforce because the rights could have been given to someone else and reposted without the *rights holders* permission.

So yeah I'd say it's probably an arse covering exercise, actually ripping off someone elses IP wholesale is unlikely.

[Catharz]

I'd imagine that you're also not allowed to post copyrighted material.

[cthulhu]

Yeah, but because I've violated the TOS doesn't mean that the rights holders rights are impacted.

Which is why WoTC trying to use material on the boards in their own public is probably a high risk exercise.

[Prak]

I know I'm being paranoid, but I want to protect my stuff. It's knee jerk, but I don't like what wizards is doing.

[JonSetanta]

I make Will save versus Bullshit Lawyering attack (Ex).

Quite simply: no. My stuff is mine, legal or not. I may not be articulate on the matter, but that dictum just wrong.

Not that I've posted much of value on Wizards in the last 2-3 years anyway...

[Interested2]

They are indeed Edisons of the Coast in the sense that they torture puppies and kittens.

[Prak]

1188183290[/unixtime]]They are indeed Edisons of the Coast in the sense that they torture puppies and kittens.

actually I was referring to the fact that edison stole the work of his undergrads/interns/lab assisstants/etc. but it's good to see I'm not the only one who doesn't fawn over the idiot...

[Crissa]

That TOS clause has failed in court at least once (see Yahoo! vs volunteers) so it's not really a CYA but a poor attempt to say that all material submitted to them is theirs - which is a clause that has been supported.

Just remember to make point not to publish things on their website first - that means that the publisher of record is the prior one, not them, and their submit clause can't be used.

On a more relevant point... Who wouldn't want them to use the rules suggestions posted by themselves?

-Crissa

[Count Arioch the 28th]

1188183453[/unixtime]]

1188183290[/unixtime]]They are indeed Edisons of the Coast in the sense that they torture puppies and kittens.

actually I was referring to the fact that edison stole the work of his undergrads/interns/lab assisstants/etc. but it's good to see I'm not the only one who doesn't fawn over the idiot...

Tesla was the man.

[Prak]

1188186058[/unixtime]]That TOS clause has failed in court at least once (see Yahoo! vs volunteers) so it's not really a CYA but a poor attempt to say that all material submitted to them is theirs - which is a clause that has been supported.

Just remember to make point not to publish things on their website first - that means that the publisher of record is the prior one, not them, and their submit clause can't be used.

On a more relevant point... Who wouldn't want them to use the rules suggestions posted by themselves?

-Crissa

good to know.

Tesla was the man.

hell yeah.

[Koumei]

Tesla even looked cooler.

[JonSetanta]

Russia has all the cooler sciences, ranging from winning the space race and (to this day) ESP experiments. As an American, I'm torn between an attitude of "hey, but this isn't such a bad place to live" and "wow we really do suck compared to Russia."

They have proved psi exists and the rest of the world still goes about nosepicking and wondering if telepathy is a farce????

Tesla is awesome. Glad your guys brought him up hahaa

But at least our American food is good. Mostly.

[Koumei]

They have proved psi exists? Sweet.

[tzor]

PSI? Pounds per Square Inch ... yea that exists.

The United States is still the nation of Ben Franklyn, who was the first American Scientist who had a cult following ... oddly enough in France. I mean he slept late, he drank too much, he was good friends with the Marquis de Sade, and he was beloved in France!

Edison, on the other hand invented (actually one of his lackys - Harold P. Brown did the dirty deed) the electric chair because he wanted to give the screws to a competitor (George Westinghouse) whose idea of AC current was superior to his idea of DC current.

George Westinghouse, Jr ... HE ROCKS!

[Koumei]

1188229785[/unixtime]]PSI? Pounds per Square Inch ... yea that exists.

Lies! There is no such thing... as... a unit of measurement that won't stop existing just because I deny it.

I need to think these things through a bit better.