Judging__Eagle wrote:K wrote:fectin wrote:Clever. How do you learn enough Indian history to do that without being offensive?
Slightly related: Steampunk Central Africa: awesome setting or racist landmine?
Landmine.
Any advice on how to
not make it a landmine though?
You
can't. See the bottom line is that when we make French or German or Russian expies for a fantasy game,
that's kind of racist. Actually, it's just plain racist. There's really no way to boil down real people to genre tropes without leveraging racist stereotypes.
The reason why we go ahead and make the "like Italy" and "like Scotland" fantasy kingdoms is not because it isn't insulting to those people, it's because those people can take it. And they can take it because they are rich and privileged. We can prank on them, and they know that it isn't a prelude to taking away their right to vote or own property, so they can laugh along with it.
We can make all the dirty stupid Viking jokes we want, because the Norwegians are the richest people the world has ever seen, and Norwegian-based racist tirades are simply taken in stride. They know that there has literally never been as privileged a group in the history of the Earth as the Norwegians, so Norwegian racist jokes simply come off as
ironically hilarious. It's like making "Yo momma's so poor..." jokes about Donald Trump. It's simply not hurtful, because wealth and privilege has made those people immune to those kinds of injuries.
On the other hand, Central African people are regularly denied access to food, shelter, and medical care, let alone citizenship privileges like fair treatment in a court of law, representation in government, or police protection. Saying racist things about Congolese or Luba people is really
hurtful in a way that making fun of the Welsh simply hasn't been for over two hundred years.
This is why you knew that "World of Darkness: Gypsies" was going to be wholly unacceptable
no matter what was in it. We actually don't have to read the contents of that book to know that the book as a whole is a hate crime. Now, if you actually do read it you'll find yourself regularly seeing red and wanting to vomit because it's
really really bad. But the fact is that it's literally impossible to introduce racial stereotypes of marginalized people and have that not be offensive and horrible.
Now I know what you're thinking. You're thinking "Hey, if we can't talk about marginalized colored people in RPGs, doesn't that contribute to their marginalization by reinforcing the Eurocentrism of our discourse?" And the answer of course, is
yes. It's a big problem.
-Username17