How would you redo spells in D&D?
Moderator: Moderators
- Psychic Robot
- Prince
- Posts: 4607
- Joined: Sat May 03, 2008 10:47 pm
How would you redo spells in D&D?
Outside of balancing them, what system would you use? Traditional Vancian? Spells per encounter? Recharge magic? Skill- or level-check casting?
Count Arioch wrote:I'm not sure how discussions on whether PR is a terrible person or not is on-topic.
Ant wrote:You do not seem to do anything.Chamomile wrote:Ant, what do we do about Psychic Robot?
- PoliteNewb
- Duke
- Posts: 1053
- Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2009 1:23 am
- Location: Alaska
- Contact:
I'm probably going to go vancian, just because a.) I'm lazy, and b.) I don't mind limited resource management (I kinda like it).
That said, the variant I'm tinkering with is a more broad-based spell system, where you can get a spell at any level, and what it does is limited by your caster level (which will probably just end up being character level) and what slot you choose to cast it in.
For example, if you know the "Concealment" spell, depending on how high level you are and what slot you want to use, it can do a variety of things, ranging from making you less noticeable in a crowd, to hiding objects from view temporarily, to making you blend in with the wall if you're not moving, to letting you simply fucking vanish in broad daylight.
There will be a variety of spells of this sort, with names like "Beast-mastery", "Pyromancy", "Spellbinding", "Necromancy", "Telepathy", "Demon Trafficking", and so on and so forth.
That said, the variant I'm tinkering with is a more broad-based spell system, where you can get a spell at any level, and what it does is limited by your caster level (which will probably just end up being character level) and what slot you choose to cast it in.
For example, if you know the "Concealment" spell, depending on how high level you are and what slot you want to use, it can do a variety of things, ranging from making you less noticeable in a crowd, to hiding objects from view temporarily, to making you blend in with the wall if you're not moving, to letting you simply fucking vanish in broad daylight.
There will be a variety of spells of this sort, with names like "Beast-mastery", "Pyromancy", "Spellbinding", "Necromancy", "Telepathy", "Demon Trafficking", and so on and so forth.
Drain ala Slayers d20
Koumei wrote:I'm just glad that Jill Stein stayed true to her homeopathic principles by trying to win with .2% of the vote. She just hasn't diluted it enough!
Koumei wrote:I am disappointed in Santorum: he should carry his dead election campaign to term!
Just a heads up... Your post is pregnant... When you miss that many periods it's just a given.
]I want him to tongue-punch my box.
The divine in me says the divine in you should go fuck itself.
- Bill Bisco: Isometric Imp
- Knight
- Posts: 447
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 1:12 am
Forget spells per encounter, or per day, but per lifetime! Once you cast that fireball a third time, you need to make a new character to cast it again, and you better damn hope you've levelled by now to get a new spell to cast (also limited by 'times per ever').
Last edited by virgil on Thu Oct 08, 2009 2:09 am, edited 1 time in total.
Come see Sprockets & Serials
How do you confuse a barbarian?
Put a greatsword a maul and a greataxe in a room and ask them to take their pick
How do you confuse a barbarian?
Put a greatsword a maul and a greataxe in a room and ask them to take their pick
EXPLOSIVE RUNES!
-
- Prince
- Posts: 3295
- Joined: Sun May 25, 2008 4:22 pm
I'd do a mix of at will, encounter and per level. And rituals for the noncombat stuff.
Last edited by RandomCasualty2 on Thu Oct 08, 2009 2:21 am, edited 1 time in total.
Better carry around a crossbow, then! Or get issued something like the magic missile (sic) of DnD4.0, which is *completely* different than just carrying a crossbow.
Kaelik, to Tzor wrote: And you aren't shot in the face?
Frank Trollman wrote:A government is also immortal ...On the plus side, once the United Kingdom is no longer united, the United States of America will be the oldest country in the world. USA!
- traverse
- Apprentice
- Posts: 58
- Joined: Sat Jul 19, 2008 10:32 pm
- Location: Our house, in the middle of our street.
Sounds like the Bio-Mage. Crazy.virgileso wrote:Forget spells per encounter, or per day, but per lifetime! Once you cast that fireball a third time, you need to make a new character to cast it again, and you better damn hope you've levelled by now to get a new spell to cast (also limited by 'times per ever').
In one of my projects, Mystery!, I have mix of at-wills and incantations. But I could never decide on a specific system for every setting. Some settings just operate differently. I've used skill-based before, but didn't really like it. At-wills are certainly my system of choice.
I would let any spell caster have a number of spell slots equal to the highest spell level they could cast, plus their spell casting ability modifier. And they could regain their spell slots and change the number of spells prepared after a 10 minute ritual. DCs remain the same (10+ spell level + ability modifier). Metamagic would instead of increasing the spell level, cost an additional spell slot per spell level increase.
-Kid Radd
shadzar wrote:those training harder get more, and training less, don't get the more.
Stuff I've MadeLokathor wrote:Anything worth sniffing can't be sniffed
That Bio-Mage seems to be the worst class, ever. Worse than the 3.5 Wilder. A class that actively kills you if you use you class abilities?! Oh Rule 34 30, I curse thee for thy unending torment. That I now must live my life knowing something so filled with fail in the purest form exists, is too much to bear. My life shall be as hollow and empty as the cursed knowledge that has made me thus: That which is seen may never be unseen.traverse wrote:Sounds like the Bio-Mage. Crazy..
Last edited by Hicks on Thu Oct 08, 2009 7:38 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-Kid Radd
shadzar wrote:those training harder get more, and training less, don't get the more.
Stuff I've MadeLokathor wrote:Anything worth sniffing can't be sniffed
- NineInchNall
- Duke
- Posts: 1222
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm
Assuming the spells were balanced for it: Recharge + Fatigue. I'd also have some sort of limit on the spells available, sort of like the Known vs. Readied dichotomy from ToB.
Last edited by NineInchNall on Thu Oct 08, 2009 3:45 am, edited 2 times in total.
Current pet peeves:
Misuse of "per se". It means "[in] itself", not "precisely". Learn English.
Malformed singular possessives. It's almost always supposed to be 's.
Misuse of "per se". It means "[in] itself", not "precisely". Learn English.
Malformed singular possessives. It's almost always supposed to be 's.
- Josh_Kablack
- King
- Posts: 5318
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm
- Location: Online. duh
Assuming we're still talking something called D&D, I'd still keep a somewhat Vancian system.
I'd either go all the way back to Card--based: you play a Fireball card to have your character cast a fireball spell or I'd go with Wizardry I's simplified system (IE the 3.x sorcerer), where you get so many spells per day to cast of each level known, but it doesn't matter which spells within a level you cast. Thus if you have 3 3rd level spells per day, you get to cast 3 fireballs, or 3 lightning bolts, or 3 hastes, or 1 of each, or 2 of one and one of another.
The card-based system allows you to have a number of different options for how to refresh your hand (preparing your spells) and opens up some other mechanics (claiming last card played, peeking at other's hands, etc)
I'd either go all the way back to Card--based: you play a Fireball card to have your character cast a fireball spell or I'd go with Wizardry I's simplified system (IE the 3.x sorcerer), where you get so many spells per day to cast of each level known, but it doesn't matter which spells within a level you cast. Thus if you have 3 3rd level spells per day, you get to cast 3 fireballs, or 3 lightning bolts, or 3 hastes, or 1 of each, or 2 of one and one of another.
The card-based system allows you to have a number of different options for how to refresh your hand (preparing your spells) and opens up some other mechanics (claiming last card played, peeking at other's hands, etc)
"But transportation issues are social-justice issues. The toll of bad transit policies and worse infrastructure—trains and buses that don’t run well and badly serve low-income neighborhoods, vehicular traffic that pollutes the environment and endangers the lives of cyclists and pedestrians—is borne disproportionately by black and brown communities."
I remember working up a system in high school meant to simulate the magic system of Eragon (ie, words of power, the more you know, the more you can do).
It was a spell point system that allowed anyone to cast. Several races got inherent spell points, and all that was particularly required was a knowledge check appropriate to type (Arcane, nature, religion:arcane, druid, cleric) with a sliding DC based on spell level. If you didn't have enough spell points to cast the spell, it'd spill over into Con, and cause fatigue, and yes, you could nova and die.
I liked it, I don't know how well it'd work out, and it likely needed a hell of a lot of polish before seeing the table, but I thought it fairly decently reflected the magic in the book.
It was a spell point system that allowed anyone to cast. Several races got inherent spell points, and all that was particularly required was a knowledge check appropriate to type (Arcane, nature, religion:arcane, druid, cleric) with a sliding DC based on spell level. If you didn't have enough spell points to cast the spell, it'd spill over into Con, and cause fatigue, and yes, you could nova and die.
I liked it, I don't know how well it'd work out, and it likely needed a hell of a lot of polish before seeing the table, but I thought it fairly decently reflected the magic in the book.
- RobbyPants
- King
- Posts: 5201
- Joined: Wed Aug 06, 2008 6:11 pm
I'm trying something like this currently in a game I'm running. The classes grant spells known/readied each level, but I'm using spell points for casting (with a modified mechanic for direct damage scaling). Right now, the group is too low of a level for me to get a good feeling for it. When all you're slinging around is 1st level spells for 1 SP, it's not much different than pick-and-choose-Vancian.NineInchNall wrote:Assuming the spells were balanced for it: Recharge + Fatigue. I'd also have some sort of limit on the spells available, sort of like the Known vs. Readied dichotomy from ToB.
Last edited by RobbyPants on Thu Oct 08, 2009 12:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Vancian. Maybe allow simple "magic tricks" as there exists today to allow casters something to do when they run out of Vancian allotments, to still work within their profession. Like those silly illusions with extremely limited time and application use. The banana peel cantrip comes to mind, as well a puff of air to flicker candles, etc. Nothing really big in an of itself, but if used right, then so be it that such a little freebie could do massive damage. Like the banana peel causing something to fall off a cliff to its death....that isn't the spell, just good tactics by a savvy caster. Of course they would have to be figured out for each spell users. Cantrips, orisons, etc.
Play the game, not the rules.
good read (Note to self Maxus sucks a barrel of cocks.)
Swordslinger wrote:Or fuck it... I'm just going to get weapon specialization in my cock and whip people to death with it. Given all the enemies are total pussies, it seems like the appropriate thing to do.
Lewis Black wrote:If the people of New Zealand want to be part of our world, I believe they should hop off their islands, and push 'em closer.
-
- Serious Badass
- Posts: 29894
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm
Things that are, or can be, analogous to working for a living - such as long term conjuration, fabrication, and healing should indeed be limited by time. I suggest drawing on things that are more explicit than "per day" like "per full moon" - but really, whatever.
Magical combat actions should just give you random options each turn. Any resource management system for combat spells is just there to make people be more interesting to watch than an Akuma player. There's really no reason or benefit to bother keeping track of resource expenditures from round to round.
-Username17
Magical combat actions should just give you random options each turn. Any resource management system for combat spells is just there to make people be more interesting to watch than an Akuma player. There's really no reason or benefit to bother keeping track of resource expenditures from round to round.
-Username17
As much as I love “Vancian” magic, the dichotomy between slotted power units (casters) and unlimited, useable almost every round (fighters) makes balancing things downright impossible. People want the best of both at the same time.
So I am tempted to go with the way 4E does things now. The problem is that there is no technical problem for a fighter to hack at things 24/7 but there is for a caster to cast 24/7. The idea of “combat” being the only medium for spells is arbitrary nonsense. Therefore there needs to be something else that could be equally applied to fighters as well as casters. A fatigue system would be a nice way to handle this without the arbitrary nonsense of 4E terminology.
(In fact the 4E system of combat / non combat could be called a crappy way of putting fatigue into the game, considering how tightly controlled the encounter guidelines are for adventures.)
So I am tempted to go with the way 4E does things now. The problem is that there is no technical problem for a fighter to hack at things 24/7 but there is for a caster to cast 24/7. The idea of “combat” being the only medium for spells is arbitrary nonsense. Therefore there needs to be something else that could be equally applied to fighters as well as casters. A fatigue system would be a nice way to handle this without the arbitrary nonsense of 4E terminology.
(In fact the 4E system of combat / non combat could be called a crappy way of putting fatigue into the game, considering how tightly controlled the encounter guidelines are for adventures.)
- CatharzGodfoot
- King
- Posts: 5668
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm
- Location: North Carolina
Yeah, the nice thing about "fatigue" is how it seems reasonable for both magical and physical performances.tzor wrote:A fatigue system would be a nice way to handle this without the arbitrary nonsense of 4E terminology.
The law in its majestic equality forbids the rich as well as the poor from stealing bread, begging and sleeping under bridges.
-Anatole France
Mount Flamethrower on rear
Drive in reverse
Win Game.
-Josh Kablack
-Anatole France
Mount Flamethrower on rear
Drive in reverse
Win Game.
-Josh Kablack
-
- Knight-Baron
- Posts: 593
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm
Rule 34 is "if it's on the internet, there's porn of it." So what you're talking about is apparently porn of people who kill themselves using their magic. So magical snuff sex? Yeah, there's porn of it. But really.Hicks wrote:That Bio-Mage seems to be the worst class, ever. Worse than the 3.5 Wilder. A class that actively kills you if you use you class abilities?! Oh Rule 34, I curse thee for thy unending torment. That I now must live my life knowing something so filled with fail in the purest form exists, is too much to bear. My life shall be as hollow and empty as the cursed knowledge that has made me thus: That which is seen may never be unseen.traverse wrote:Sounds like the Bio-Mage. Crazy..
[d'oh ]Clearly, you are misquoting me. I believe my post was edited to be rule 30.[/d'oh]
-Kid Radd
shadzar wrote:those training harder get more, and training less, don't get the more.
Stuff I've MadeLokathor wrote:Anything worth sniffing can't be sniffed
For a spell system, I'd like have them like act building blocks with feat selection enhancing them, whereby high level spells are reflected by low level spells. The base spell might be (for example) a touch (or very short range) blast of X (where X is a element selection based on a feat that you can plug in) and it will increase in potency as you level with no cap. Feats like Ranged, Ray, Area of Effect etc. may be bought, and tacked onto the base spell as you wish. The spell itself would describe what the feat selected would do, hopefully this would help stem the spell writing bloat.
As for spell casting I'd rather go something like that would have a limited number of casts and spell selection (which could be changed with difficulty) by encounter, while mashing all the spell lists together and requiring you to take a theme. There would have to be built in limiters on some of the "non-encounter spells" (timers is one way) to ensure casters don't go hog wild out of combat.
As for spell casting I'd rather go something like that would have a limited number of casts and spell selection (which could be changed with difficulty) by encounter, while mashing all the spell lists together and requiring you to take a theme. There would have to be built in limiters on some of the "non-encounter spells" (timers is one way) to ensure casters don't go hog wild out of combat.
-
- Serious Badass
- Posts: 29894
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 7:54 pm